Ranking of the most controversial Nobel Peace Prizes

It seems a long tradition in history that the “Nobel Peace” laureates are ambiguous and controversial. So we are trying here to make a ranking of the Top 5:

5) Cordell Hull, 1945:

cordell-hull-1

Hull, a US politician, was given the prize for his role in establishing the United Nations. He is a controversial winner because of an incident in 1939 when he was President Roosevelt’s Secretary of State. The President was amenable to helping 950 Jewish refugees aboard a ship called the SS St. Louis settle in America. But Hull and a group of Democrats from the American South voiced “strong opposition”, threatening to withdraw support for Roosevelt if he let the ship dock. The president buckled, the SS St. Louis was turned around and many of its passengers became victims of the Holocaust.

4) Henry Kissinger, 1973:

kissinger

When President Nixon’s Secretary of State was handed the prize in 1973, American satirist Tom Lehrer observed that political satire was dead. Kissinger was a joint winner of the prize alongside North Vietnamese leader Le Duc Tho. Both men had help broker a ceasefire in the Vietnam war, but Le Duc Tho turned the honour down saying peace had not yet been restored in South Vietnam. Kissinger accepted the award “with humility”. Kissinger’s critics point out that the US was still carpet-bombing Cambodia the year he picked up the prize. He’s also been accused of war crimes, thanks, in part, to America’s provision of arms and support to the South American dictators who carried out Operation Condor, an anti-communist campaign of repression and terror that claimed the lives of thousands of people.

3) Yasser Arafat, 1994:

Yasser-Arafat_2753860b

One man’s freedom fighter is another man’s terrorist. Arafat, who led the Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO) for three decades, was handed the award alongside Israeli PM Yitzhak Rabin and his foreign minister Shimon Peres. The trio were cited for their work on the Oslo accords which created “opportunities for a new development toward fraternity in the Middle East”. Supporters compared Arafat to Nelson Mandela, says Time. Opponents called him an “unrepentant terrorist with a long legacy of promoting violence”.

2) Wangari Maathai, 2004:

wangari-nobel-1

The first African woman to win a Nobel Peace prize died in 2011 at the age of 71. The New York Times describes her as an “environmentalist, feminist, politician, professor, rabble-rouser and human rights advocate” who created jobs for women and an organisation that planted trees across Kenya in a bid to fight erosion. The day before she was due to collect the peace prize in Stockholm, a story appeared in an African newspaper that claimed she had likened AIDS/HIV to a “biological weapon” and told participants in an AIDS workshop that the disease was “a tool” to control Africans “designed by some evil-minded scientists.” Maathai confronted the storm of controversy by insisting her comments had been taken out of context. “I neither say nor believe that the virus was developed by white people or white powers in order to destroy the African people,” she said in a statement released by the Nobel committee. “Such views are wicked and destructive.”

1) Barack Obama, 2009:

Obama-e-la-gang-della-marijuana_h_partb

Riding high on the goodwill sparked by his election victory the previous year, Obama was a popular winner. At the time, America’s first black president said he didn’t deserve the award. Four years down the track, plenty of people seem to agree with him. In an article published by the Daily Beast last month, Kirsten Powers says it’s time for Obama to give his Nobel Peace prize back. She cites his determination to attack Syria, with or without a UN Security Council resolution, as one reason; the escalation of a “pointless and failing” war in Afghanistan is another. But the main reason Obama should turn in his prize is his “five-year Middle East drone war” which has killed an estimated “500 to 800 innocents”, writes Powers.

Special MentionAung San Suu Kyi

clinton-gallery-horizontal-gallery

Read the full article: The “pop” Lady: between lust for power and victimhood and more: Myanmar’s ‘Muslim-free’ election after Aung San Suu Kyi’s purge , You wanted the bike? Now pedal. , The ferocious secret wars of the Lady of Peace

 

Thanks to: The Week UK for the idea